View Our Practice Areas

Man appeals DUI conviction, saying he wasn't drunk

Utah residents may not have heard about the appeal of a man convicted of DUI in a vehicle that arguably wasn't drivable. In the early morning hours of Dec. 12, 2010, police were notified of a broken-down vehicle sitting in the outside lane of traffic on an interstate in the northeastern part of the country. When a police officer arrived, he found a man behind the wheel of the car. The man was arrested for DUI and later convicted. He appealed his conviction stating that he was not really drunk driving since the car was not in motion.

According to court documents, the vehicle did not have all four tires and looked as though it had been in an accident. The police officer that responded to the call observed that the man sitting behind the wheel of the car smelled strongly of alcohol and was slurring his speech. The man failed several breath tests and had to have blood drawn at a local hospital in order to establish his blood alcohol level, which turned out to be 0.143. This level would be considered intoxicated in most states, including Utah. 

In his appeal, the man accused of drunk driving petitioned to have his conviction overturned based on the fact that the officer could not place him behind the wheel of the car when it was involved in an accident. He claimed there was no evidence that he had actually been the driving the vehicle, drunk or otherwise. He asserts that he has no memory of being involved in an accident.

It may be arguable on appeal whether or not a driver can be found guilty of DUI if the vehicle is not moving. However, in this case, the court rejected this defense. The court was somehow convinced that the man was, in fact, drunk driving when the accident occurred.

Source:, "State court backs DUI conviction of driver who sat on I-81 in wrecked, tire-less car," Matt Miller, June 20, 2013


  • I can’t speak highly enough of Kris and his team. I was always kept informed and educated on my options and potential outcomes. Kris was so professional and helped me feel at ease through a very difficult and emotional process. His expertise is second to none and you truly feel as though you’re in the best hands. Thanks for everything Kris, I consider you a great friend!Read more...

    — Tyler H.
  • Rand Lunceford was my attorney and he did a great job for me. Was always very quick to return phone calls and texts. Gave me court reminders the day before. And did a great job. when it was all said and done I was extremely impressed with Mr. Lunceford and their firm. Read more...

    — Brittany U.
  • I appreciate Michael's professionalism and willingness to listen to his clients. He truly cares for them and tries to see things from their perspective. That approach is refreshing and really helps in drawn-out cases. Michael is easy to get a hold of and quick to work on cases. Read more...

  • Brian attended mediation with us today and he was a rockstar. He was very knowledgeable and thorough. I don't know what we would have done without his well-informed counsel and the way he stood up for us. He maintained a calm and authoritative demeanor, even in the presence of the 4 other attorneys on the other "sides". We will be recommending him to anyone who needs a family law attorney, and we'll be choosing him if we ever need one again! Read more...

    — Tawny A.
  • Not to sound cliché... Justice was served!! I have never been in a situation to need a Lawyer. Lauren really stood up for me when forces were making a situation much larger than it should have been. Our situation was extremely difficult but choosing this law firm was the best chose i could have made for my family and I. I am so grateful that Lauren was in my corner fighting while I took care of my family. Words cant Express my gratitude. It is unfortunate that accusations can place people in situations that you cant handle or control...fortunately there are great people like Lauren Forsyth. Wonderful person, Great Lawyer! Read more...

Speak with an experienced lawyer.

If you need help with a divorce, family law issue, DUI or criminal defense, complex civil litigation, or real estate matter, we are here for you. To schedule an appointment with one of our dedicated attorneys call us at (801) 475-8800.

Email Us For A Response

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Office Locations

Ogden Office
195 25th Street
Suite 304
Ogden, UT 84401

Phone: 801-475-8800
Fax: 801-475-9800
Map to Ogden Office

Park City Office
136 Heber Avenue
Suite 305
Park City, UT 84060

Phone: 435-655-3680
Map to Park City Office

Lehi Office
3450 N. Triumph Blvd.
Suite 102-161
Lehi, UT 84043

Phone: 801-753-5650
Map to Lehi Office

Salt Lake City Office
299 South Main
Suite 1300
Salt Lake City, UT 84111

Phone: 801-317-8968
Phone: 801-534-4410
Map to Salt Lake City Office